![]() |
| Nazar Suraksha Kavach |
It’s like he’s the only one concerned with what’s happening
around the country and pardon my French…like hum sab bas ch***ye bethe hain… as if staring at someone with keen
intensity accentuated by soft lighting and adequate depth of field is going to
solve the poverty of people’s backs. I understand one needs to play the
emotional card, because without it Indians ko
kuch samajh nahi aata, but I have enough people preaching their moral
superiority to me everyday and I can do without another one.
But before I move on to talking about how the show told me
more about us as people than it did about the issue it chose to address, I want
to get some stuff out of the way.
Aamir Khan: Contrary to how annoyed I am with the marketing blitz;
I actually have no beef against Aamir Khan doing the show. The intention is
noble, and props to him for even trying something like this on Indian
television. He’s using his star power to “raise awareness”, and while
personally I will always skeptical of that terms intangibility, I hope some
good will come of it. What and how? I don’t know, and I don’t even think anyone
cares. People are just happy that Aamir Khan is “doing something”! And we as a
people seem so starved of role models and hope that even “doing something” is
enough to get them on your side.
One of the biggest challenges within the development sector
always remains impact assessment – so while I don’t expect massive “societal
change” (the term rich people use to say we hope poor people reach our level
someday before making sure they never do) to happen through the show, it’ll definitely
get rich people to think about the issues it raises through its run. (I like
how rich people keep saying the show is meant for a “DD Audience” – our of
saying poor bastards – because for us everything that is wrong with society
only happens amidst these poor fuckers who dirty our streets and have no civic
sense and have the audacity to ask for something more than minimum wage and
more than one holiday a year while they clean our houses)
Again, parts of the show made me cringe (Aamir’s opening
monologue – and the song in the end interspersed with pictures of helpless kids
that we as society have wronged – straight out of the aao videshi tourists se gareebi ki numaish ke zariye paisa nikaalte
hain playbook) but let’s face it – shots of people crying and a painful
story are what work to get people’s attention and there the producers got their
desired results.
The show: I don’t know why people are bothered about Aamir
charging 3 crores per episode. Like any other professional he’s spending his
time and effort making the show and will/should be compensated for it. I know for
a fact that some of my friends who have been working their assess off on the
ground for a pittance will be irked at so much attention being showered on
issues they’ve been crying hoarse about for years and years purely because
Aamir Khan has said it – but that’s just how we’ve become. We can’t eradicate
polio till Amitabh Bachchan tells us its fucked up, so I don’t know why we’re
surprised now. I am curious to see how sensitively issues are treated and
whether the research is accurate – and I hope I won’t be disappointed given how
television is forced to stick to broad strokes. I’m looking forward to the
piles of academic literature that will flood JSTOR and the likes once the show
is done, and how friends working on the ground and on campus react to it. On
many levels, it is and can be a critical show.
The people’s reaction: The best thing that Satyamev Jayete
did for me however was providing an insight into how people (using Twitter as a
sample) thought. It immediately became taboo to even make jokes about Aamir
Khan simply because “he was doing something and all we were doing was
tweeting”. It’s almost as if you had to qualify yourself as having good karma
before being able to comment on the show incase you didn’t like it. So what is
it then? Does one have to had donated a certain amount of money to charity,
spent x number of years working with an organisation, personally saved 8 kids
from a fire? Why must one be chastised for not liking the show or joking about
it?
It’s amazing how by just watching the show – people thought
that they had done something amazing which made them morally superior beings.
And while my first instinct was to mock it, I realized it became taboo to mock
the show simply because Satyamev Jayete - for that moment - became a beacon of
change. For that brief period, it became more than just a television show – and
cheesy as it sounds - Aamir became the crusader who gave voice to people’s
hope. We’ve become so disappointed and disgusted with our political and social
representatives, that Aamir Khan became that one guy we could look up to
because he seemed to have no personal agenda and was using his influence for
something other than selling biscuits.
Here’s what made me uncomfortable however. The issue dealt
with yesterday was one of female feticide and there really is no conflict
within it. No one would willingly (I would imagine) admit to not wanting a
girl, especially amongst the educated elite. So the sheer number of people who
seemed aghast at the existence of this practice across the country was on some
level – hilarious. How isolated does one have to be from the country one is
living in to not have a clue about how widespread a problem this is? It was
even funnier when rich people expressed shock at other rich people following
this practice. “YOU MEAN EDUCATED PEOPLE ALSO DON’T WANT GIRLS?” I doubt if the
upper caste farmer in Punjab who is crushed with debt and needs more male hands
to help till the land will give a shit about the show, but that it hit some
people on Twitter like a ton of bricks was very amusing.
What happens however, when Aamir talks about an issue that
is conflicted? What when an Aamir Khan talks about caste based discrimination
across religions and takes a side? What if Aamir says he is pro-reservation in
educational institutions? What if Aamir Khan is against nuclear energy? What if
Aamir Khan supports the ban on beef? These are all hypothetical questions – and
we will likely not have these answered simply because it is a television show
and Aamir cannot afford to get into so much trouble. But how will we as people
react? Will we again give him the same wholehearted support we do so now when
it offends our own sensibilities? In their heads people seem to have already
made Satyamev Jayete more than a television show – but I don’t think we’re
ready to be confronted by actual truths of our societal order. We are happy as
long as we’re making a noise about issues we’re all against – but that’s not
even a real debate. We will also avoid the real debate because we’re not ready
for it – and instead of worrying about governance deficits we will like to be
distracted by Aamir Khan for atleast he’s talking about some things we can all
agree on. And that is where the massive support we’re giving Aamir right now
seems to ring a little hollow. And that’s not Aamir’s fault at all – he’s doing
what he can with his talent and influence and that’s a good thing – I just don’t
know how much we as people are willing to be taken down that road of societal
change, especially when it offends what we believe in.
I’m going to be watching the show keenly – simply because it
has and can have so many implications. I’m sure everyone else will to, but
maybe lets keep our shit together while we watch it?



the way the show was treated was sooo wrong!!! it really trivialized the issues at hand. sorry, neither did it educate nor did it put across an opinion
I chose not to watch the show because a sanctimonious Aamir Khan is even more intolerable than a hammy SRK. I did check on the list of sponsors, though. Airtel is one of the main sponsors, and has reduced SMS rates to Re 1 for the special code for this show. Proceeds to go to charity. *Ahem*. So people can now feel good about having done their bit for the girl child this week, casteism the next week, racism the week after... Who says push-button activism can't work, really?
the entire show just feels so wrong. it trivialized the issues at hand. it didn't educate nor did it out across an opinion.
This is one the finest program from Amir Khan. It will become big hit in coming
days.
Regards,
"satyamev jayate"
nicely written post...the intentions of the show were good but the way it unfolded made me think whether this was the Indian oprah winfrey show,plus the over the top reactions by in house audience and camera zooming in to cash in on them seemed shoddy to me.
How detached are you from the country you are living in to not know that there are many in the social and economic elite who have absolutely no idea what the world is beyond the doors of their air-conditioned cars? Schools and colleges do not teach what goes on in the rural areas. Most urban kids dont even know how rice is grown. Even though I am as skeptical as you about actual change being brought about by the show, if Aamir makes those socially unaware people aware, the show will have served its purpose.
Hi
I've been a fan of yours ever since I read your open letter to Sania Mirza on fly you fools website. I've since then followed ur blogs and i genuinely like ur brand of comedy. I don't know if I've missed any other similar posts but i really liked this particular blog. It was well written and i completely agree with where ur coming from as I was feeling the same after watching the show.. Thumbs up.. Keep up the good work..
Can I, for once, ask the other question: Why is it so important to make fun of everything? And just what escapes comic insensitivity? I am not, for one moment, doubting your freedom of expression for wanting to generate content out of a popular trend or topic.. but I'm just asking very sincerely if there is anything one can do to not get fun made of? Because honestly, just like cheesiness and platitudes, subdued irony and the shock-and-awe of comedy is also getting a bit old. Especially when comedians use generalization as their favourite methodology.. (incidentally, that's not broad strokes at all.)
What is also disturbing is that it is important to make fun of something immediately. Before people have made up their minds about an issue, the comedians have already trashed it.. so you know, if you're cool and have a sense of humour, why would you even waste another 10 seconds thinking about it for yourself? The news of someone's death only triggers an opportunity to revive the worst facts about them and joke about it. It's really the worst time to die for celebrities, don't you think, when nobody wants to remember their good work because they don't want to be the last person to post that HILARIOUS one-liner.
Well, yes, easy to guess.. I am both a person who finds it distasteful and yet has never asked someone to not do it - who wants to get the very original freedom of expression/ interpretation line thrown in their face anyway? (Doesn't matter, still gonna get called a troll.)
In this particular case though, would be nicer if some of us didn't value their cynicism so very highly. I mean, geez, you can go back to being cool and nonchalant the next day.. allow yourself a few hours of being appreciative about SOMETHING! I have heard so much about Aamir Khan's scowl in the last few days like he's personally scolded some people driving past on the highway. I have a feeling that it would have been the same if he had been smiling. Or dancing. Or singing. Maybe Chetan Bhagat had a point when he said we love to hate celebrities. You being something of a celebrity yourself should know a thing or two about that. Everything they say is disregarded more easily, nitpicked finer and dissected deeper.
A good review of the show.
I share the same fear: the majority of apathetic Indian TV viewer will simply wet their eyes with a bag of popcorn & go to bed.
What I liked about the show is that there are instances in between the talk where he shares facts and tried to break mental blocks by breaking common myths e.g. gender of child is dependent on the mother etc.
As the tagline of the show claims, if it won't hurt, it won't make a difference.
So the rona-dhona shown made sure the producers run to their banks happy while the audience empathize too. Either way, it's a win-win situation.
We all know a mass societal revolution is a far-fetched dream, but even if it ignites a few people and educate the rest, 3 crores per episode is a small price to pay. What say?
What troubles me most is that we Indians need a third party to show things which are right infront of us. Eventually when the thing is thrust upon our face we make all right kind of noices and then do nothing.
i didnt understand what you wanted to say , i think you got confused yourself
"Props to him"? Tch, tch..
I second what darkandcomic has said. It is so easy to quickly jump on a situation (like a horny man on Kate Upton) but only a few can suck it up and let the beauty of the situation be larger then their very own piece of mind. I mean give someone a "bloody" break for having the balls to actually "DO" something.
I second what darkandcomic has said. It is so easy to quickly jump on a situation (like a horny man on Kate Upton) but only a few can suck it up and let the beauty of the situation be larger then their very own piece of mind. I mean give someone a "bloody" break for having the balls to actually "DO" something.
Thank you for writing this. Some sanity is still left in this world. I was about to write an article and paste it up my FB wall when I saw this and realized that I didn't need to do that; this article is perfect!
While you have analysed quite in detail on what the intentions of the show are.
I guess its fair to question your intention. Maybe, you are writing a blog against the show to boost your social media presence.
Not to accuse you, the point being - Is the show making impact to the people watching it? Are more youth inspired to take action in the grassroots level?
"straight out of the aao videshi tourists se gareebi ki numaish ke zariye paisa nikaalte hain playbook"
I dunno how this always works in our country. Slumdog millionaire, Arvind Adiga and now Satyamev Jayte...The funny thing is that a lot of blue colored educated poeple watch all this shit and they think they have done their bit for the country. The middle class or the lower middle class doesnt need Aamir Khan to eductae them because they are the ones majorly facing all the problems. Sad that all the efforts put behind to eductae the bourgeois has gone waste and now we need Anna Hazare and Aamir Khan to awaken them.
I didn't watch it either because it pisses me off how Aamir thinks of himself as some kind of national messiah. The show is a farce!
जो व्यक्ति गर्भ में
बेटियों की हत्या करते हैं उनके
लिए यह बात है. हमेशा याद
रखना : अगर बेटा वारिस है, तो बेटी पारस है |
अगर बेटा वंश है, तो बेटी अंश है |
अगर बेटा आन है, तो बेटी शान है |
अगर बेटा तन है, तो बेटी मन है |
अगर बेटा मान है, तो बेटी गुमान है |
अगर बेटा संस्कार, तो बेटी संस्कृति है |
अगर बेटा आग है, तो बेटी बाग़ है |
अगर बेटा दवा है, तो बेटी दुआ है |
अगर बेटा भाग्य है, तो बेटी विधाता है |
अगर बेटा शब्द है, तो बेटी अर्थ है |
अगर बेटा गीत है, तो बेटी संगीत है |
" SAVE GIRL CHILD " ,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Really liked the way you have tied us into knots on this issue. Found it extremely funny.:)
Also what was your point again ?
Oh Twitter was hilarious on Sunday. The whole I'm better than you because I sent an SMS and promptly tweeted about it bit was just downright funny.
I share your views about the show. I find it weird how we're a pot pourri of contradictions. Just waiting for Aamir to talk about corruption and bribery so I can threaten to hulk smash every pandu briber I know who SMSes Y to that 7 digit no.
Major Lou.
Another two important points are:
1. Also what can be expected out of a show that is funded by Coca-Cola and Reliance??? Is it herald of mainstream corporate funded activism..where the themes will have control in hands of corporates? Kind of creating smokescreen in front of some issues that deserve most urgent attention.
2. Is'nt using 'Satyameva Jayate' a part of National Emblem for commercial use illegal as per :
THE STATE EMBLEM OF INDIA (PROHIBITION OF IMPROPER USE) ACT, 2005 which says
Para 4. "No person shall use the emblem for the purpose of any trade, business, calling
or profession or in the title of any patent, or in any trade mark or design, except in such cases and under such conditions as may be prescribed."
Now yeh.. we know he is spreading good word around.. but its a commercial use of the Emblem. Had it be not Aamir but some activist.. he would never be allowed to do so. Here no one will object.
3. At the end of it all.. it ends with call for money.. that too centralized collection with one chosen organization. Will the number of SMS n other money be kept transparent? If the show's focus is action n individual change than it should not end up reducing things to financial contributions.
Yes the show will definitely sensitize people on issues covered...but on other hand it will narrow down people's approach towards activism.
People might hate this comment but may be they still have to explore the things deeper to know what this comment wants to communicate.
Thanks,
Peace
think of the people who are actually suffering. yes, aamir is not the first to work for this social causes. there are lots of people working for the same cause at grass-root levels. but consider this show and all the future episodes as a unofficial judgement on the issues. the most important thing about this show is that it separates right from wrong at a subconscious level. for me personally, it gives strength to the sufferer to raise his/her voice against because the show has endorsed the right side of it.
For all the people who watched the show, shed tears, and then tweeted about it...thank you! Thank you for not doing more. One of the scariest things in the development sector is when a bunch of half-informed, emotionally charged fools rush in to 'solve problems' (Kony anyone?). So I am perfectly happy with people staying on their couches feeling like they're helping the cause.
As for these friends in the dev sector who have been working their asses off on the ground, stop bitching and use the momentum and free publicity to get some funding for an effective project. You're not Aamir Khan, so let him do his thing, and you do yours, and hopefully we can channel the attention in a productive way.
All I hope for this episode is for women who have endured these abuses to feel less helpless and alone, and maybe speak out or fight back (this bit is the idealist in me; please don't bite). And to wipe the smirk off the faces of the fuckers (and fuckerettes) who force and practice sex-selective abortion and female infanticide. It's a start (though the dev sector friends will howl that they started first).
If you dislike the show & Aamir khan so much then why exactly will you be "watching it keenly"? Why not just change your TV channel & watch something else if it disgusts you so much? Just so that can have more jokes to make on Twitter?
You might care about the issue and feel that all this is moral preaching but quite obviously there are millions of people who are not aware of the severity of the issue & for whom it'll be a wake up call rather than preaching. If after watching the show even a handful of people who were otherwise going to consider abortion just because it's a girl reconsider their decision then don't you think all the marketing blitz is worth it?
And let's face it. Female infanticide exists and on a daily basis girls are killed. Maybe not by you or by other people you may know but they definitely do. If the show reaches the level of discussion it aims to reach & changes the mind of people, then why not?
And again, if you find it was all preachy to you & it was looking down on you as some sort of morally incompetent person, then why watch it?
I agree with the Dude!!! You have written a very intelligent note above, but I think at least Aamir is trying to highlight these issues. Everyone knows about them and they are prevalent in our very homes, but if he educates or brings about a change in .005 people, it might be worth it... The first episode was a bad edit and a lot of real footage was removed since the tears didnt match with what was happening on the show, but I'm sure, future episodes will have a better connect.
The question is not what Aamir is charging or whether he is right or wrong, but as an individual of this country, at least he is trying. The Shahrukhs of the world are only busy making money and more money. He makes a RaOne and screws up crores of rupees to please his kids... what a waste!
All said and done Aamir is in a league of his own and believe me he has shed a lot of tears and realised what happens in this beloved country of ours jispar hum sabko bada naaz hai!!!
Understand where you come from but disagree with the blog. 'Everybody knows' what Coke/Pepsi are but the companies still find the need to employ Amir and other celebs to endorse them. Some idiots won't know about the issues until Amir talks about it, others will remain unaware until Oprah talks about it; you'll still find many blind to the issues even if you kidnap their kin and say tere maa behen mere kabze mein hain. Multiple avenues are needed, just as you might write a blog and then post links to your blog on twitter and facebook.
The blog should probably need to be resurrected when Amir stands for parliament, though.
Understand where you come from but disagree with the blog. 'Everybody knows' what Coke/Pepsi are but the companies still find the need to employ Amir and other celebs to endorse them. Some idiots won't know about the issues until Amir talks about it, others will remain unaware until Oprah talks about it; you'll still find many blind to the issues even if you kidnap their kin and say tere maa behen mere kabze mein hain. Multiple avenues are needed, just as you might write a blog and then post links to your blog on twitter and facebook.
The blog should probably need to be resurrected when Amir stands for parliament, though.
I fail to understand this criticism...would you be more happy if he came up with some weird reality show instead? In fact tell me what will make you happy? I guess you are one of those people who try to find fault in everything. Freedom of expression is fine but at least whatever you express should make sense not just trying to be different. If everyone is praising something i must find some fault. Aamir has used every thing necessary in this show..i think its very well thought, planned and executed. He has tried to appeal to people's emotional and rational mind. The entire presentation is so powerful that no one remain un-impacted. I say, if even one life is saved after this show, this show has served its purpose. Need i say more?
I am ashamed at your opinions and jokes made by you.Do you have the guts to even try to address such issues? I am sure neither are you a woman who has faced such son/daughter discrimination from in-laws or such coercion nor even seen it happen around yourself.Do you know how painful it is for a woman as a mother when she is asked to choose to love sons more than daughters.
Get a life and instead of making jokes on people's effort do something nobel.It's very easy to write funny stuff but as 'dark and comic' and Paul singh said, have the balls to try to change things.Orelse please don't crib about the state of society in India.
I am sure you have not heard shameful and degrading remarks about such social menaces from our foreign friends!
India has a lot of serious problems which are widespread and pervasive in society. In many other societies a single incident of such atrocities would be unimaginable and would instantly cause outrage.
Some good examples are rape, casteism and racism.
Most Indians know rape is wrong, and it invokes strong negative emotions among them, but on the other hand, most Indians do not even realize that they are horribly racist or casteist (if that's even a word). Why don't we realize this? And even if we do, why don't we think it's terrible? Then the problem is of mindset. Since we see such behavior all around us, we grow up to think that it's not a issue. Similar arguments can be made for lack of civic sense, gender equality, widespread poverty, corruption, etc.
This show will hopefully raise awareness about why such practices are horribly wrong and should be unacceptable as opposed to 'chalta hai'. The concept and motive of the show is not unique and news channels/DD routinely air shows with a social conscience where one of the agendas is to hold a mirror to society and educate us.
I feel that it's important for a country like India with such a huge population and such a fucked up mindset to have more and more of these kind of shows.
I know you agree with everything I've said so far, and it was all #NoShitSherlock. This was just to reestablish the context for what I want to say next.
Any show should be subject to criticism, mockery and comic ridicule. (That's freedom of speech and that's our right. In fact it's quite important to do so cause we take ourselves too seriously and are easily offended. So, well done!) What is also important to understand here is that rather than only mocking and making fun of such shows it is important to acknowledge that the effort is commendable and to endorse the core message. Specially so because of the Indian context.
In the end it's a personal choice and one doesn't have to put a disclaimer to be allowed to crack jokes.
But if all we do is mock everything and anything then what are our opinions (expressed via jokes/satire/commentary) even worth?
One of the reasons why comedians/satirists like George Carlin and Jon Stewart are regarded gold is cause they have a social conscience, and from time to time they express their opinions too, rather than only mocking all the time.
--WolframZeta
India has a lot of serious problems which are widespread and pervasive in society. In many other societies a single incident of such atrocities would be unimaginable and would instantly cause outrage.
Some good examples are rape, casteism and racism.
Most Indians know rape is wrong, and it invokes strong negative emotions among them, but on the other hand, most Indians do not even realize that they are horribly racist or casteist (if that's even a word). Why don't we realize this? And even if we do, why don't we think it's terrible? Then the problem is of mindset. Since we see such behavior all around us, we grow up to think that it's not a issue. Similar arguments can be made for lack of civic sense, gender equality, widespread poverty, corruption, etc.
This show will hopefully raise awareness about why such practices are horribly wrong and should be unacceptable as opposed to 'chalta hai'. The concept and motive of the show is not unique and news channels/DD routinely air shows with a social conscience where one of the agendas is to hold a mirror to society and educate us.
I feel that it's important for a country like India with such a huge population and such a fucked up mindset to have more and more of these kind of shows.
I know you agree with everything I've said so far, and it was all #NoShitSherlock. This was just to reestablish the context for what I want to say next.
Any show should be subject to criticism, mockery and comic ridicule. (That's freedom of speech and that's our right. In fact it's quite important to do so cause we take ourselves too seriously and are easily offended. So, well done!) What is also important to understand here is that rather than only mocking and making fun of such shows it is important to acknowledge that the effort is commendable and to endorse the core message. Specially so because of the Indian context.
In the end it's a personal choice and one doesn't have to put a disclaimer to be allowed to crack jokes.
But if all we do is mock everything and anything then what are our opinions (expressed via jokes/satire/commentary) even worth?
One of the reasons why comedians/satirists like George Carlin and Jon Stewart are regarded gold is cause they have a social conscience, and from time to time they express their opinions too, rather than only mocking all the time.
--WolframZeta
Ashamed of the fact that you are making fun of someone's efforts to try to bring about some change.These shameful social issues are actually giving India a bad image globally.
I guess you are still to see or listen to people make fun of India.Privileged people like you won't know how a woman feels as a mother when she is forced to choose between a son/daughter.Specially when she takes same amount of pain and time to give birth to both.A mother can never love any child born of her less or more than her own other children.
I guess only a man can have the heart to make such jokes.I am sure when you face any such thing in or around your family you will be crying blue murder.But if someone attempts to change or eradicate such social menace they are laughed at.People laughed at Einstein too, but today physics students swear by his theories.Even if it took Amitabh Bachchan to make people think about polio, Mr. Writer, India has been polio free for the last one year.Which is a commendable feat.
Instead of being cynical or funny about such serious issues, think how you can make a difference. As they say' Badlaav humein se hoga'.
But well trying to make people like you understand is like'bhains ke aage been bajana' . You people are heartless selfish slobs who are so busy in your own life that you don't care what happens to some poor unfortunate people.
If you are stating that Aamir's intention is noble and is using his star power to raise awareness, then you are contradicting yourself in the first two paragraphs
I am also not sure why your friends who have been working on the ground for pittance are being irked by all the attention. Isn't it finally positive that the issues which they have passionately campaigned about is getting global audience due to Aamir?
Also your view of "The people's reaction" is really "your reaction". You have not conducted any polls or surveys to garner the reaction of the "people" towards this show.
The whole point here is no one is sure if a societal change will occur but the seed to use the right to think has been sown through this show because it is criminal not to even think.
Also, I am surprised if you did not express shock at a man biting his wife's face like an animal, a mother-in-law kicking a new born baby off the stairs and a woman have to forcibly get a abortion 8 times all for not wanting a girl child ! It is in poor taste to ridicule someone's ignorance.
Change has to occur, not sure how...but this is a good start...support the cause because we don't want this to happen to our children or our grandchildren in the distant future !!!
well said. reminds me of CNN's "light a candle" for the tsunami. or "light a candle" for paris hilton's nights in jail, or some such nonsense.
You make a fair point, and to that end, I agree with you .... however, the urban elite have so far remained blissfully unaware .... After AK (who I believe has good intentions plus a capitalistic spirit - 3crores?!) - after AK bombards them with all the statistics and horrific stories .... the urban elite of India will remain blissfully aware - a few of them might turn a page, but most of them would go about their daily lives of demanding subsidized petrol and then crying about government deficits, avoid customs & duties on imports, and then wonder why the government is printing money causing inflation.
Hello,
Being an educated person myself..I was certainly not aware about the extent female foeticide crimes have been on for..I was under the impression that it has slowly started to phase out and it happened only in rural areas/villages. However, Aamir Khan's show sure brought out facts. I have always believed that fingers are always lifted at those who try and do something good for other's and for the society cause people always think 'Ohhh he/she must earn something out of it' or than the most famous situation when it comes to a celebrity is simply that 'He/she is just doing it for publicity.' That is not always the case! Aamir was a supporter of Anna Hazare and I would certainly not doubt him wanting to bring around a change in the society for EVERYONE'S GOOD. Be it fame too but don't try to pretend like you are blind either!
It is also very shocking how all you people weren't moved or affected by the cases that were brought to the viewers notice in the show. Don't you think it's a shame how the doctors were smiling and supporting female foeticide and yet they were promoted and allowed to practice medicine? Do you'll absolutely not feel anything at all? A common person/journalists sure tried fighting it out at Rajasthan..and what was the result? They getting harassed and receiving notices for being arrested! It's a shame to even read and listen to such things cause all you people on the blog can do is make fun of someone who's trying to improve the society and not help other's out! If you all are that smart then why cant you'll do something too on our own? Have you'll not watched the show properly to see what the judge's decision was when a mother tried to fight for her child?? And for you Khamba..No one asked/forced you to watch the show..If it annoys you so much then simply shut your television or change the channel to something else that would please you, if Satyamev Jayate's hoarding is in your face take a different route to travel or DO NOT look up to it!! If you like forcing yourself than DON'T GET YOUR A** ONLINE AND COMPLAIN.
I truly loved the show and I will definitely support the causes no matter which part of the world I maybe in..!
*Satyamev Jayate*
I agree with you on the obvious milking of Indian emotions done by the show.But I would like to point out that the show will bring a lot of awareness about the issues being addressed.. for eg.: even though female foeticide is a current problem in India, in many parts of the country(especially the educated southern states) it is considered a myth or something that just happens occasionally in rural areas... As a guy from Kerala, I was flabbergasted about how prevalent sex discrimination is in the northern states even among the educated elite
If you think Aamir is using his star power to raise awareness, then whar are you doing here..??
You are just using your humor and dumb wit to contemplate a serious issue to get some more hits on your blog. Thats all.
You should really understand what should be made fun of and what not.
The show is meant for diverse audiences. So, it will obviously befriend some and alienate some, even seem insulting to intelligence for a select few. Yup, I can understand how irritating it can be when you have larger-than-life posters staring down on you making you feel small. That said, it's a relief for me that there is no moralistic judgment being made in the show. It seems like a genuine attempt by Aamir Khan, leveraging well on his celebrity status to do something right. I can understand how it can piss off activists who slog & still cannot have the impact Aamir Khan has. Nett nett, while Aamir Khan is in a position where he can individually have tremendous impact (which is unsettling), what is heartening to note is that the show does not over-reach its bounds. It is a show for the masses, end of the day.
every Topic which Aamir will talk about will a subject in itself and how much a single episode will achieve is indeed doubtful .
The exercise is futile until Aamir starts taking sides on conflicting subjects because may be,hopefully, then atleast then this country will start debating !!!
Perhaps you could try this for a change. How about, the next time, you make fun of the ones who are actually responsible for this pogrom. Mock and ridicule and adopt that famous condescending tone to chastize the ones who, quite shamelessly, go about killing girls in the womb, the doctors who proudly participate in the 'business' of female infanticide, the ones who force women to undergo abortion over and over again, and on each occasion without the mothers knowing about it or even having a say in it. How about standing up for their freedom of expression? You do know what that term stands for, don't you?
Or will I too be labelled as a celeb basher, just like you?
i watched your show but i disagree with the facts that journalists showed,,it became one sided,,,the show would have called upon one of the doctors of rajasthan who knew in and out of the case but who was not involved so that the show would not have become one sided,,i would also reflect light upon the issue that journalists said that no action was taken against these doc but let me tell you these doctors suffered and their license of practising was cancelled for about 6 months,,so GUYS KINDLY PAY ATTENTION AND DON;T ONLY JUDGE BY THE THINGS THAT WERE SHOWN AS NO BODY HAS SEEN THE OTHER SIDE OF THE COIN..
cynical n confused at best...i mean is this an attempt to praise the show or mock it...after every crib about aamir and the show there is a line of praise for the effort...r u shy of praising it openly that u had to wrap it up in mockery...5mins wasted!
That's right. Stay put and write condescending blog posts. After all, getting your butt off that chair takes too much work. You and your ilk are victims of your own apathy. Make all the fun you like of the way someone else tries to clean the shit that surrounds you all, but in the end my friend, the joke is squarely on you.
My doubts have been confirmed....It is the educated Bourgeois which did not know the prevelant problems in our country who liked the show and got educated by it....thats the whole point WHAT THE FUCK WHERE YOU DOING when it was out in the papers...rather WHERE THE FUCK WERE YOU? You were readin a tabloid which wrote bout how AAMir is going to do a show on social issues then...You SAD FUCKERS need a coke and reliance sponsored show and a 3 crore per episode pseudo intellectual mindless celebrity to teach you how your country has shaped after zillion years of independence.....
for all the people educated by the show SAD YOU ARE REALLY REALLY SAD
AAMIR KHAN IS A GOOD ACTOR. PERIOD.
PAID 3 CRORES OR MORE PER EPISODE HE CAN CHANGE FROM A NATIONAL HERO TO GIVING US SONGS LIKE BOSEDK..
HE HAS THE ABILITY TO EVEN USE PEOPLES CRITICISM AS A MARKETING GIMMICK, LIKE HE DID AT THE HULLABALOO CREATED ON THE DOUBLE MEANING OF THE ABOVE SONG.
RIGHTFULLY HE SHOULD CONTRIBUTE SOME %AGE OF HIS CHARGES TO THE CAUSE. THE REST TO MAINTAIN HIS YOUTHFUL LOOKS.
HOWEVER,IF HE CONTINUES TO MAINTAIN HIS EXPRESSION FOR TOO LONG, WILL SOON END UP LOOKING LIKE A CHINESE.
Very well said and totally agree with you.
I completely agree with you....
A very good review of the show.I think people should know and care about this issue but as you clearly pointed public needs some leaders or stars to motivate them. So good if Amir can provide that push. Secondly the research of the show was very good except the tears drama(I think that was a director thing). I was aware of all the facts barring that how Female infanticide started and places like nawansahar was able to control it. That was new for me.
hey khamba, ek computer screen ke saamne baith ke kisi ki,pardon my french, G***d maarna bahut aasan hai. See I believe that whatever he is doing, he is trying to spread awareness and putting facts about things we dont even think to care about (DOont know about the "Intellectual" You, Atleast I thought that female feticide was a thing of the past, and things have improved since, and was of the opinion that it is a thing more prevelant in the rural areas, just like the Punajbi farmer of you blog who needs more hands to till his farm). Dude I dont know if you can "donate a certain amount of money to charity, spend x number of years working with an organisation, or personally save 8 kids from a fire" but you can do a lot of better things than just sitting infront of a computer and criticising everything around. And just so that you know, Aamir Khan doesn't give a shit about what a,pardon my frnch again, "Ch****a" Khamba thinks about his endeavors, but Khamba on the contrary has all the time in the world to write and critically "Analyze"(my,ass) what he does. You know what you dont care about joking or putting your open views on your blog, all you have in mind or care about, is how to grab attention of people, by just talking about something everyone knows about. This is the extent of how fucked up you are. Dude, if you really feel you are too good a critic, and have the right words to use at the right places, then work for the governemt or use your talent for the country, rather than just wasting it on Joking about anything around, just to gain attention and make you blog famous. Better luck next time!
Satyameva Jayate is a catalyst to change. Here's why
1. Awareness and dialogue
2. Purgation and sharing of grief- collective mourning if I may
3. Makes rational arguments with emotional treatment
4. Makes us question our education and elitism
This country lacks platforms for civic discussions, if a tv program can do its bit to this cause what harm?
@unleasher dude u are really good at french.....
Embryoctony is a big issue in india.
people says that it happen in rural area bat i want to know one thing that a what about Dowry system?
reach father buy a boy on a big ammount for her daughter but what about a poor father?
Embryoctony is a big issue in india.
people says that it happen in rural area bat i want to know one thing that a what about Dowry system?
reach father buy a boy on a big ammount for her daughter but what about a poor father?
i would like to throw some light on the facts that were not shown in the show,,because the journalists in your show said that no actions were taken against these doc..bt
1.7 years back the govt. immediately suspended the concerned doctors in service
2. locked up the private clinics
3. terminated the practising license for 6 months to 1 year
4. lodged f.i.r
5. and the matter was sent to honourable court of law
so I WOULD LIKE TO DRAW THE ATTENTION OF EVERYBODY ON THESE facts
i don't understand that why only the doctors are held responsible for this crime despite of knowing the fact that the people who accompany that particular woman are equally or slightly more responsible and punishable,,
so that the sex ratio that is deteriorating would be balanced,,,
Man... u write really good...
i am becaming a great fan of ur's.
You have the view of a realist, which is exactly what we need when we watch the show. It may not be perfect, but it sure does move you, and inspire you to act. Question is if the change is going to be significant enough or not...
All the HATERS and YOU Khamba! IN YOUR FACE! the result that Satyamev Jayate got in just a few DAYS!!
http://www.ndtv.com/video/player/the-9-oclock-news/the-satyamev-jayate-effect-trps-for-a-cause/231764?pfrom=home-topstories
Here's My article about the same Issue,Not that good though.. http://thatindianboy.blogspot.in/2012/05/why-i-think-satyameva-jayate-isnt-going.html
I can totally understand the psyche with which this blog is written but I find this blog quite lame. There are reasons for that:
1. For most of the part, it looks like you have problem with the show just because Aamir Khan is doing it. Why are you letting your prejudices blind you and doubt the efficacy of the show.
2. Just to bash the show, you are speaking the language of the people who do it. You almost look like their representative. I wonder whether you actually consider female foeticide an issue!
3. As far as the questions about effectiveness of the shows and its methods are concerned, I hope you have come across the Star Fish story - Hundreds of star fish lying on the shore. One kid starts picking and throwing them back in the sea. Grandfather says -"Son, there are thousands of them. You can't give all of them life by throwing them in the sea. It won't make any difference." The kid replied - "It made a difference to that one!", after throwing another one in the sea. I might be coming across as an impractical, emotional fool but... The point is, even if 1000 people in 1 Billion change their opinion about sex selection, I would consider the show effective!
iam the big fan of aameer baba but satyam does it duits him so fcuk
Quite a few pertinent points made in your post. While I had reservations about the first episode as well as definitely considered an Indian Oprah Winfrey etc, what I think today is that here's one show that is speaking about taboo issues relegated to academic papers, journals, books and a few media discussions post a "sting" operation or a gruesome crime comes out,for the first time on Indian television, on a Sunday with a wealth of viewiers. True, we are disgusted with politicians. True, we have a tendency to pick scape goats and hide behind them. True, we are a nation of charisma politics. And yes, this show is sponsored by corporates and at the end there's a silly SMS gimmick.
But there's something I learnt while working in the wildlife conservation field for sometime. The government will stall, corporates will leech, mine and kill. But what little you can do to conserve,a tiger here, a leopard there, a sanctuary declared, a campaign announced; what little you can do to get people to start talking about an issue, you must make that effort.
Aamir Khan might be self-righteous, might be trying hard to come across as a conscious person despite promoting phosphoric acid containing coke. But his show is getting people to sit up and talk. He is using his charisma and fan following to sit and highlight some issues.
After the female foeticide program, my mother; a playschool teacher, the wife of a naval commander came up to me and asked me naively, "Sharada, When do we know the sex of a child in the womb?" A mother of two, who had two cesaerans, a tubectomy doesn't know her own body. An example, a statistic among millions of women in this country who don't know the bodies they inhabit.
I think the show began working for me then. :)
Dear mr author, awareness is the first step towards any change in society. Rome was not built in a day. It takes tremendous effort and patience on the part of society as a whole and concerned individuals in particular to make even little progress in a country of billions, which has relatively recently gained independence ( as compared to the developed world) and is plagued with ignorance and poverty, which ultimately are the root of all evil.
I have a few questions to all pseudo-intellectuals and arm chair cynics like you:
1. What is wrong with making money while doing something with a good intention? I am sure everybody, probably even you want to do. I am a child specialist. I treat children with sincerity and make money at the same time. If AK would have taken up any other project like a game show, that would have paid him too. What's wrong if the sponsors are willing to pay. It ain't blood money, after all.
2. What is wrong if a AK is photographed with a particular look on his face? The creative heads may have decided that the particular shot may get more people to be intrigued into watching the show....means towards an end. How is your freedom of expression greater than their freedom of expression?
3. Why should your friends working at grass root levels be irked by AK grabbing limelight. Work at grassroots level and mass communication are both in dependant yet synergistic approaches towards consolidating any change in society, specially if it involves mindsets. If they are genuinely concerned with the results, they should be happy that people will now be more appreciative of their work, as they will be more aware.
4. What's wrong with a person trying to undertake a social responsibility? Isn't it everybody's secret wish (I am sure, including even yours) wish to contribute to society, even if in a small way. Most people don't have the courage to do so, lest somebody may ridicule them.
5. Can the gift of gab and satire only be used to ridicule? Is there no discretion involved?I am not a fanatic and neither am I unappreciative of humor. However, I am disappointed that somebody who has the gift of expressing himself and the ability to make even a drab topic interesting and humorous could help in completing the task that AK was unable to achieve perferction in. I wish I were in a position where you are where what I write could influence somebody's thought process.
6. How many people knew about the stats presented in the show, even if we largely know about the issue of female feticide? I, for one was under the impression than the rates of female feticide was dwindling, at least in educated and elite social circle. This show really made me sit up and take notice.
7. Who would not be moved by the grotesque and moving stories of suffering women presented on the show? If all this is happening in society, it needs to presented to the general public too. Tear jerker or not, these stories are too shocking not to be told
In the end, there are myriad uses of the pen ( for example, you may shove it up your, pardon my french, ass and twirl it a few times. Please don't mind, it's just my freedom of expression). But how you use it depends on your choice. It doesn't your moral ground higher than anybody else's
There have been a lot of ‘tweets, retweets, likes, shares, comments, blogs, agreements & disagreements’ on much famous ‘Satyamev Jayate’
Am not Aamir Khan fan, but this is for the good work he’s done and is doing:
‘All the critics please understand, its not about how much or how many people will remember what he said on the show, what’s important is that HE took the effort of saying it, which is definitely registered in the subconscious minds of people watching the show.
I am defiantly sure if not all, but FEW will surely act against the evil of the society. That would be big achievement. For that I SALUTE him.’
"It’s like he’s the only one concerned with what’s happening around the country and pardon my French…like hum sab bas ch***ye bethe hain"
i can SAY the same for you!!
m not a fan of aamir khan and neither of this show!
what am saying is..what actually the so-called mango-people are doing?
watching his bullshit and now reading your bullshit!
some people are screaming that show is so good..he is so right..and some are just making fun of him like you!
nobody is actually doing a THING!sending a Re.1 sms to support the cause is not a real support!! but yes...if someone has actually went to the bank and gave some hard-earned money for charity has all the rights to criticise this topic!
because that person has actually done something!!
and i have more respect for him/her than i have for aamir khan...he is just an entertainer and someone who is taking money to support the cause which is related to everyone!!
as simple as that.
I agree with u!
From a similar debate going on my FB page just because I made a critical comment on
1) Aamir's buckets of tears shed in the first episode 2) people who had never ever bothered about any of the problems facing the nation suddenly shouting 'STOP FEMALE FOETICIDE', 'BAN SEX-DISCRIMINATION' 3) people reacting as if Aamir Khan had suddenly discovered that India faced ‘Female Foeticide’ on 6th May 2012 – I had a million comments ‘justifying’ why Aamir Khan was ‘Great’ because he was doing such a ‘great show’…
I was surprised because at the end I kept expecting that he would stand up and say ‘Mere 3 crore rupye mein se, I will divert 3 rupees to these lost cases’ …but no, instead he entreated us to send SMS and make donations! So in the end he has just pimped himself like all the others, except that instead of acting like a fool in some silly reality show, he has chosen to ‘ACT’ in this show. So yes, I will give him.
Again, the show does NOT present both sides of the coin, There might be people who would have indulged in female foeticide and turned over a new leaf. Why not have them come on to the show?
The most unbelievable thing for me was people suddenly ‘waking up’ and saying ‘What educated people also do this?’…..
What about all the activists who have been fighting for years on these issues and never been acknowledged?
Like my brother says, if Aamir Khan scoops poop off the streets with a spoon and eats it, people would applaud him for his spatial co-ordination and go around announcing that ‘Poop is now edible’. And this coming from Aamir Khan fans.
It was a good experience to read the articles and contents on this site.
http://www.deccansojourn.com
i watched a couple of episodes of the show and got bored of it. almost all the issues discussed in the show by aamir khan have been in the papers or on television in the past 2 years. but i guess it really does take a celebrity with good dialogue delivery and tear shedding here and there to make a crowd go hoo and haa. i guess this is where i say 'RIP newspapers'.
i second your thought, people expressing shock on issues so widespread is lame. where the f*** do these people come from anyway? don't they read the papers?
and my sincere advice to the producers of the show. come up with slightly original content that hasn't been overexposed in the media already. some of us get sick of it.
Its our general tendency not to accept our faults..Fact is India is facing some challenging issues and if Amir is making use of his popularity to bring about a change whats wrong?not only problems are being discussed on this show but possible solutions are also being highlighted.we may keep debating about contents or impact of show but the reality is at least he has made an honest attempt to do something rather than join the crowd of cynical loosers who only believe in criticizing .
The number of comments itself clarifies that you rode well on the trending topic but don't you think that talking "bullshit" all the time would only harm you as brand? You have been writing well but what happened on this post?
Your last post just got 5 comments on on this you already have 70 plus - make fun/ask on the trending topics and you are done. I guess you owe something to the society too. I am not a BIG fan of this program OR Aamir but yes if someone says things well appreciate them. Being "pissed off" all the time is damn boring NOW.
Your well wisher
I was at the Comedy Store yesterday and saw you dish out your usual angst ridden rants. Needless to say I thoroughly enjoyed myself. But, I'm sure it would have come as no surprise to you when all your political satire received only a low key response..... I'm looking forward to seeing your gig again....
Satyameva Jayathe-This is an awareness program. There could be lakhs of people, watching this show desiring or intending to bring a reformation. At least the 1st step towards this venture is already done. Aamir cannot be a reformer and that was not his intention or our expectation. . As a journalist you also spread this awareness and do not really act as a reformer. Let's see what happens after 13 weeks. Tthere is a seed of desire in many a mind and one day or other there could be the birth of a reformer here or there.
Hope you watched the impact analysis episode today. it proves your argument wrong for a lot of times :)